For nearly a decade, buying a home in Greater Rochester often meant preparing for a bidding war. Multiple offers, homes selling above asking price, and buyers competing for limited inventory became the norm.
But lately, I'm seeing something we haven't experienced much in recent years: negotiation.
In some transactions, buyers have more opportunities to negotiate price, repairs, closing dates, and other terms. Bidding wars haven't disappeared, and sellers still have significant advantages in many situations. But the market is changing, and both buyers and sellers need to adjust.
Here's what I'm seeing and what it means heading into 2027.
Buyers Are Getting More Room to Negotiate
For years, buyers had very little leverage. A desirable home could attract dozens of offers, leaving little opportunity to negotiate. Sellers simply chose the strongest offer, and everyone else moved on.
That's not happening with every listing anymore.
Some homes still receive multiple offers, but others are attracting fewer buyers or sitting on the market longer. That creates opportunities to have conversations that were much harder to have just a few years ago.
Buyers may have more flexibility when negotiating purchase prices, inspection items, closing dates, and other contract terms.
My advice? Don't assume you have to offer significantly over asking price or waive important protections just to get a home. Every property is different. Understand the competition, evaluate the home's value, and develop a strategy before submitting an offer.
Sellers Still Have an Advantage, But Strategy Matters
More inventory doesn't automatically mean it's a buyer's market.
Rochester continues to have relatively limited housing supply, and well-priced homes in desirable locations can still move quickly.
However, sellers should recognize that buyers have more options than they did during the height of the bidding wars.
Pricing a home correctly, preparing it for the market, and investing in professional marketing can make a meaningful difference.
The days of assuming every home will receive multiple offers regardless of its condition or asking price are not something sellers should count on.
A thoughtful pricing and marketing strategy is more important than ever.
Buying and Selling at the Same Time? You Have Options.
One of the biggest concerns I hear from homeowners is figuring out where they're going to live between selling their current home and purchasing their next one.
The good news is there are several ways to approach this situation.
Depending on your circumstances, options may include:
Negotiating an extended closing date.
Arranging a temporary rent-back after selling your home.
Exploring bridge financing or buy-before-you-sell programs.
Coordinating the sale and purchase to minimize the gap between closings.
Every situation is different, but homeowners shouldn't assume they have to sell first and figure everything else out afterward.
Having a plan before listing your home can make the entire process considerably less stressful.
First-Time Buyers: Don't Count Yourself Out
One mistake I see first-time buyers make is assuming they can't afford to purchase a home before they've even explored their options.
They see headlines about high prices, interest rates, and bidding wars and decide homeownership isn't realistic.
Sometimes the numbers don't work. But often, buyers simply need help understanding their budget, identifying opportunities, and figuring out what makes sense for them.
Not every home will be the right fit, and not every property will be affordable. But there may be opportunities buyers haven't considered.
The key is having an experienced agent who understands the local market and can help develop a realistic plan.
What Happens Next in Rochester Real Estate?
The biggest factor I'll be watching heading into spring 2027 is inventory.
If more homes continue coming onto the market while buyer demand remains relatively restrained, we could see additional opportunities for negotiation.
But Rochester is a seasonal market, and spring typically brings renewed activity. It's too early to know exactly how that will play out.
I don't expect every home to suddenly become a bargain, nor do I think the competitive market we've experienced will disappear overnight.
What I would like to see is more balance.
Buyers deserve opportunities to make informed decisions without feeling forced into extreme competition. Sellers deserve to receive strong value for their homes. And agents need to be prepared to negotiate effectively for the people they represent.
After years of a market where the highest offer often won, we're seeing a renewed importance placed on experience, strategy, and negotiation.
That's a good thing for real estate.
Thinking About Buying or Selling in Greater Rochester?
Whether you're purchasing your first home, selling a property you've owned for years, or exploring your next investment, understanding the market is the first step.
At the Anthony Butera Team, we work with buyers and sellers throughout Greater Rochester to develop strategies that make sense for their individual goals.
If you're considering a move in 2027, let's talk.
Visit AnthonyButeraTeam.com to connect with our team.
For additional reading, Jason was recently featured in KeyCrew's article, After a Decade of Bidding Wars, Rochester, New York, Is Relearning How to Negotiate.





